2 conflicting interpretations/rephasings of a Question

[sachin.w]

Have a doubt with regards to mods..

say Question is squareroot[(x-5)^2]=5-x?

Now,
since on gmat, squareroot of negative numbers don't exist, this Question can be rephrased as
is (x-5) > 0?
or x>5?--------------1

but
since squareroot[(x-5)^2] is |(x-5)|, Question can be rephrased as
is |(x-5)|=5-x?
now since |(x-5)| cant be negative,
it can again be rephrased as
is 5-x>=0?
which is
is 5>=x?
or
is x<=5?------------2

How can there be 2 ( 1 & 2) interpretations ? I guess I am missing something here ... Please help..

[tim]

your first rephrasing is wrong and doesn't follow at all from any mathematical conventions used on the GMAT..