Things to remember about Radford is:
- Emotional response to the art is genuine.
- But they are irrational
- because people know it is not real.
Let's go to the answer choices.
A) Believing oneself to be in a battle is not exactly emotional response. And this answer choice is unclear on whether this person knows what he/she saw was real or not.
B) This would be negating some elements from Radford's argument.
feels nothing <-> genuine feeling
rationally <-> irraltionality
realizing not a real event = knowing it's not real.
The bottom line is that B) doesn't exemplify Radford's argument.
C) "Writing" isn't same as perceiving the art and feeling emotional response.
D)
"irrationally" - check
"even while realizing ... fictional event" - check (knowing it is not real)
"bust into tears" - check (genuine feeling)
Correct
E) Completely non related to this.